EDITORIAL: Is Lady Justice under attack? Or is this a county turf war?
Once again, Cook County Chief Justice Timothy Evans and County Board President Toni Preckwinkle are having at it, this time locked in a battle over how much money to spend on the courts.
Judge Evans insists he can’t make the budget cuts — and layoffs — Preckwinkle is demanding because the courts would be so short-handed that justice would be undermined. Evans’ argument would be easier to swallow if he didn’t have two daughters on the payroll, each pulling down six-figure salaries.
Work this out, Judge and Madame President. But Judge, forgive us if we see more of a turf war here than an assault on Lady Justice.
Because the county’s ill-fated new tax on sweetened beverages expired Friday, Preckwinkle and the County Board have turned to spending cuts to balance their budget, including a $200 million cut for the court system.
But Evans, represented by Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan, filed a lawsuit Thursday arguing that the demanded cuts are so deep that the county courts won’t be able to do their job properly. Moreover, Evans argues, it’s not proper for the County Board to specify particular positions in the court administration for layoffs. If there are to be layoffs or other cuts, he says, it should be up to him to decide how to make them.
On Friday, the case was delayed until Tuesday to give the Cook County state’s attorney’s office time to hire outside counsel to represent Preckwinkle’s side of the debate. At a brief hearing, the outside jurist brought in to handle the matter, Lake County Judge Mitchell L. Hoffman, urged both sides to come to an agreement.
Much of the blame for the county’s budget problems can be traced to Springfield. Under Gov. Bruce Rauner, the state has fallen millions of dollars behind in paying what it owes to Cook County and has cut some funding entirely. As of Sept. 30, the state owed $104 million, not counting the $1.6 million in rent that’s in arrears for space the county rents to the state.
Evans and Preckwinkle have a history of being at loggerheads, both in previous battles over county budgetary matters in 2011 and 2013 and in earlier days when they were perennial opponents in Chicago’s Fourth Ward aldermanic races.
This latest flap looks to us like more of the same.
Send letters to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Foxx’s office cites conflict, causing delay in chief judge’s lawsuit to block Cook County layoffs
A Lake County judge on Friday agreed to delay arguments in the case until 11 a.m. Tuesday after Cook County State’s Attorney Kim Foxx’s lawyers said they needed time to hire outside counsel because the office has a conflict of interest.
Attorneys declined to detail the conflict after the hearing at the Richard J. Daley Center, but Foxx spokesman Robert Foley later said the reason was because “the state’s attorney’s office represents the office of the chief judge in multiple cases pending litigation.” Lawyers for Attorney General Lisa Madigan, whose office is representing the chief judge, agreed to the delay.
In allowing the continuance, Lake County Judge Mitchell L. Hoffman urged both sides to engage in negotiations before Tuesday’s hearing, saying the Illinois Supreme Court has made it “very clear” in the past that it prefers not to see such lawsuits filed between separate branches of government – in this case the judiciary and legislative.
“This type of litigation should be a last resort,” said Hoffman, who was brought in from outside Cook County for the hearing.
Original story follows.
Cook County Chief Judge Timothy Evans on Thursday sued County Board President Toni Preckwinkle to block layoffs approved last week as part of a budget that was slashed in the wake of the pop tax repeal.
Evans contended in the lawsuit that “the county has no authority” to tell him who to lay off, while the courts have the authority to “compel the expenditure of resources necessary to allow the judicial branch to perform its constitutional responsibilities.”
The suit, filed on Evans’ behalf by Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan’s office, asks a judge to put in place an order that would block the layoffs and “provide sufficient funds” for the offices of the chief judge, circuit court clerk and sheriff to operate the courts. Evans also asked that a judge from outside Cook County be appointed to hear the case.
Preckwinkle spokesman Frank Shuftan said the board president hasn’t seen the court filing, “but will certainly defend the budget passed by the board.” He noted that any delay in the layoffs “will result in deeper cuts later.”
Evans’ office was hard hit by $200 million in budget cuts the County Board unanimously approved last week based on Preckwinkle’s recommendations. The spending plan called for more than 155 layoffs in the areas Evans controls — the most of any county office, department or agency.
All told, the county expects to lay off more than 320 people as part of a $5.2 billion budget for the financial year that starts Friday. In his suit, Evans noted his office would absorb nearly half the layoffs, even though it accounts for only 5.6 percent of the county operating budget.
Preckwinkle and commissioners said they were working to eliminate middle managers in offices that have too many and avoid harming front-line services. Evans instead proposed different cuts, including 20 unpaid days off for all his employees. Preckwinkle rejected that option, saying Evans had not reached agreement with the affected unions.
Evans, whose twin daughters work in his office, said the layoffs would “cause disruption to the essential functioning of the court” and would force violation of county worker union contracts.
Cook County’s Chief Judge Sues to Block Layoffs
Cook County’s chief judge has filed a lawsuit against the county board’s president and treasurer seeking to block budget cuts for the 2018 fiscal year.
CHICAGO (AP) — Cook County’s chief judge has filed a lawsuit against the county board’s president and treasurer seeking to block budget cuts for the 2018 fiscal year.
More than 160 employees in the court system are slated for layoff under a $5.2 billion budget approved this month.
Chief Judge Timothy Evans on Thursday said the lawsuit against County Board President Toni Preckwinkle and Treasurer Maria Pappas aims to make the county to take “whatever action is necessary” to stave off the layoffs.
The lawsuit was filed on Evans’ behalf by Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan’s office. It contends the layoffs would cause “disruption to the essential functioning of the court” and also force him to violate union contracts. Evans says those targeted for termination have higher salaries and more seniority.
Spokesman Frank Shuftan said Preckwinkle will defend the budg